My Old Ass on Prime Video is an unexpected and deeply moving film from Megan Park, who previously directed The Fallout. Starring Aubrey Plaza, the film centers on 18-year-old Elliott (Maisy Stella), a free-spirited teen on the cusp of leaving her small Ontario hometown for a bigger life.
After a mushroom trip, Elliott meets a dry-humored version of herself 21 years in the future, who warns her to stay away from a guy named Chad (Percy Hynes White). What makes My Old Ass stand out is its emotional depth and the powerful performances of its leads.
Stella perfectly captures the vibrancy and naivety of youth, while Plaza’s portrayal of her older, regretful self adds a layer of dry humor and heartbreaking honesty. The film avoids sentimental clichés, instead allowing quiet, intimate moments—particularly a touching scene between Elliott and her mother (Maria Dizzia)—to carry its emotional weight. With a grounded direction, My Old Ass explores themes of time, identity, and the inevitability of change.
Here’s why it’s one of the most surprising and moving films of the year.
Letter Grade: A+